Key points
- Ravi Shastri questioned Mohammed Siraj's omission from India's playing XI for the first Test against New Zealand in Wellington.
- Shastri said that when pace, skill and seam movement were selection criteria, India's difficulty in regularly reaching 140 kmph made Siraj's absence a question.
- India reduced New Zealand to 70/5 before Henry Nicholls and Glenn Phillips added an unbeaten 173-run stand.
- Nicholls finished Day 1 on 113 not out and Phillips on 94 not out as New Zealand reached 243/5.
- Jasprit Bumrah took 3/52, while Anshul Kamboj returned 1/57, Akash Deep 1/33 and Prasidh Krishna 0/58.
- India batting coach Sitanshu Kotak defended the selection, saying the team management had picked what it considered the best XI for the conditions.
Former India head coach Ravi Shastri has questioned the decision to leave Mohammed Siraj out of the playing XI for the first Test against New Zealand in Wellington, with India's pace attack struggling to maintain pressure after an impressive start on Day 1. Shastri's comments came as Henry Nicholls and Glenn Phillips rescued the hosts with a major sixth-wicket partnership at the Basin Reserve.
India had reduced New Zealand to 70/5 after winning the toss and choosing to bowl. Jasprit Bumrah led the early charge, taking three wickets, while the visitors looked set to make further inroads. But Nicholls and Phillips batted through the remainder of the day, putting together an unbeaten 173-run stand to take New Zealand to 243/5 at stumps.
Shastri, who handed Siraj his Test debut during India's 2020-21 tour of Australia, questioned the selection on social media. He pointed to the importance of pace, skill and seam movement and asked why an experienced bowler such as Siraj had not been included when India's attack was finding it difficult to generate high pace consistently.
Shastri asks: Where was Mohammed Siraj?
In his post, Shastri hoped India would bounce back but questioned the logic behind the selection. His central point was that if the team had prioritised pace, skill and seam movement for the Wellington conditions, Siraj's experience and aggression should have been part of the discussion. He also highlighted the ability of the Hyderabad pacer to make things happen with the ball.
The remark referred to the difficulty India's attack had in regularly touching the 140 kmph mark. Shastri's question gained attention because Siraj was left out even though India had selected four specialist fast bowlers for the match. The attack comprised Bumrah, Akash Deep, Anshul Kamboj and Prasidh Krishna, with Washington Sundar included as the spin-bowling all-rounder.
Shastri was not alone in questioning the call. Sunil Gavaskar also expressed surprise at Siraj's omission, pointing to the bowler's experience and recent rhythm. Gavaskar said Siraj had not let India down and found it difficult to understand how the 48-Test veteran had not made the top four in the pace-bowling options for the match.
Bumrah strikes, but New Zealand fight back
India's opening session had gone largely to plan. Bumrah dismissed New Zealand captain Tom Latham early and continued to trouble the top order with movement and bounce. Akash Deep also found an edge to remove Rachin Ravindra, while Daryl Mitchell fell to a sharp short-leg catch by Yashasvi Jaiswal. Bumrah then removed Tom Blundell to leave the hosts in serious trouble at 70/5.
However, the momentum changed as Nicholls and Phillips settled at the crease. Nicholls played with patience, defending carefully and punishing loose deliveries, while Phillips was more proactive and kept the scoring rate moving. Their contrasting approaches allowed New Zealand to rebuild without giving India another breakthrough.
Nicholls reached his 12th Test century and ended the day unbeaten on 113. Phillips was six runs short of a hundred at stumps, on 94 not out. Their unbroken 173-run partnership transformed the position of the innings and left India frustrated after the early breakthroughs.
Bumrah finished with 3/52 from 17 overs and remained India's most consistent threat. Kamboj took 1/57 in 18 overs, Akash Deep returned 1/33 in 16 overs, and Prasidh Krishna conceded 58 runs without taking a wicket in his 16 overs. The supporting bowlers were unable to reproduce Bumrah's sustained threat as the ball aged and batting became easier.
India team management defends the combination
India batting coach Sitanshu Kotak defended the selection after the day's play. He said the team management had considered the conditions and the overall balance of the side before choosing what it believed was the best possible XI. Kotak also stressed that there was nothing wrong with Siraj and that the decision was based on the combination selected for the match.
Kotak explained that India's attack included two bowlers who swing the ball well and two who rely more on seam movement, while also offering pace. He also addressed the choice of Washington Sundar ahead of Ravindra Jadeja, pointing to the four left-handed batters in New Zealand's playing XI as a factor in the decision.
The explanation did little to end the debate after New Zealand's recovery. India had created a position of control at 70/5 but could not turn it into a decisive advantage. The absence of Siraj became a major talking point because of his experience in long spells and his record in the current World Test Championship cycle.
Siraj's experience becomes the focus
According to IANS, Siraj was India's leading wicket-taker in the ongoing World Test Championship cycle, with 43 wickets at an average of 26.81 before the Wellington Test. That record, combined with his experience in overseas conditions, was central to the criticism of his omission.
The selection debate will continue as the Test progresses, but the first day's events have given both sides of the argument fresh material. India's management has defended its choice on balance and conditions, while former players have questioned whether the team left out a proven fast bowler who could have helped sustain pressure after the new-ball burst.
India will need to find a way to break the Nicholls-Phillips stand and prevent New Zealand from building a commanding first-innings total. For Shastri and other critics, the opening day has reinforced a simple question: when the conditions call for pace, experience and aggression, should Siraj have been in the side?
Frequently asked questions
Why did Ravi Shastri question Mohammed Siraj's omission?
Shastri argued that if India were selecting for pace, skill and seam movement, Siraj's experience and ability to make things happen with the ball should have counted. He questioned the decision after India's other pacers struggled to consistently support Bumrah during New Zealand's recovery.
What did Ravi Shastri say about India's pace attack?
Shastri said that 140 kmph was hard to come by from India's attack and asked where Mohammed Siraj was. He highlighted Siraj's experience, aggression and ability to create breakthroughs, while also hoping India would recover strongly in the Test.
What was New Zealand's score at stumps on Day 1?
New Zealand reached 243/5 at stumps on the opening day in Wellington. Henry Nicholls was unbeaten on 113 and Glenn Phillips was 94 not out, with the pair adding an unbroken 173 runs after India had reduced the hosts to 70/5.
How did India's bowlers perform on Day 1?
Jasprit Bumrah led the attack with 3/52 from 17 overs. Akash Deep took one wicket for 33, Anshul Kamboj one for 57, while Prasidh Krishna went wicketless and conceded 58 runs. The support bowlers could not break the Nicholls-Phillips partnership.
How did India explain the decision to leave Siraj out?
Batting coach Sitanshu Kotak defended the selection after the day's play, saying the management had chosen the best possible XI for the conditions. He explained that India had selected a mix of bowlers with different skills and included Washington Sundar because New Zealand had four left-handers.