Key points
- India were bowled out for 89 in the fourth ODI against New Zealand at Bay Oval, Mount Maunganui.
- India won the fifth ODI by 22 runs after scoring 209, sealing the series 3-1.
- Former India head coach Ravi Shastri backed Gautam Gambhir’s concerns about the team’s batting approach.
- Gambhir said New Zealand’s conditions were among the closest India could encounter at the 2027 ODI World Cup in South Africa.
- Shastri said India must show patience in bowler-friendly conditions and noted that 260-270 can be a match-winning total on some pitches.
- India were dismissed in around 26-27 overs in the fourth ODI; in the previous match, they had lost seven wickets for 111 runs.
Former India head coach Ravi Shastri has backed Gautam Gambhir’s concerns about India’s batting after the team’s difficult run in the ODI series against New Zealand. India recovered from a collapse for 89 in the fourth match to win the fifth ODI by 22 runs and take the series 3-1, but Shastri said the result did not remove the need for a more adaptable batting approach.
The concern, as described by Shastri and Gambhir, was not simply the size of the totals. It was how India handled conditions that offered assistance to fast bowlers, a challenge that Gambhir linked to what the team could face at the 2027 ODI World Cup in South Africa.
Shastri backs Gambhir’s assessment
Speaking to broadcasters, Shastri said Gambhir was right to highlight the conditions after India’s fourth-ODI defeat. He recalled Gambhir’s post-match point that New Zealand offered conditions close to those expected in South Africa, and said India should produce a better performance when faced with a similar test in the future.
Shastri’s emphasis was on application and patience. He said there would be periods when batting was difficult and players would have to negotiate them rather than continue to pursue a high scoring rate. In his view, teams could not approach every surface with the expectation of making 300-320 runs.
“On some tracks, 260-270 can be a match-winning score,” Shastri said, underlining that a total’s value depends on the conditions and the quality of the bowling attack. The former coach’s comments put the focus on reading the pitch and adjusting the innings plan, rather than measuring every performance against a fixed high-score target.
The fourth ODI collapse that prompted concern
India’s fourth ODI at Bay Oval in Mount Maunganui ended in a heavy batting collapse, with the side dismissed for 89. The team was bowled out in around 26-27 overs, according to the report. The collapse followed another difficult passage in the previous match, when India had lost seven wickets for 111 runs.
Gambhir said he was concerned when a team was bowled out for around 90, especially because the conditions were relevant to the challenge awaiting India at the 2027 World Cup. He also pointed to the speed at which the wickets had fallen. The issue, therefore, was both the low total and the inability to stay at the crease for a longer period.
Series win did not end the batting debate
India responded in the fifth ODI, scoring 209 and defending that total to win by 22 runs. Arshdeep Singh and Mohammed Siraj led the bowling effort, helping India secure the match and finish the series with a 3-1 result.
The fifth-match win showed that India could defend a modest score with an effective bowling performance. But Shastri’s comments made a distinction between winning a particular match and addressing a pattern that could become important in a major tournament. The series result did not, in his view, make Gambhir’s concerns irrelevant.
What the comments mean ahead of the 2027 World Cup
South Africa’s conditions will be a central consideration in India’s preparation for the 2027 ODI World Cup, as Gambhir’s remarks indicated. The New Zealand tour provided a recent example of the batting challenges that can arise when the ball and surface favour pace. Shastri’s response was that the team must be prepared to absorb pressure and build an innings through difficult periods.
His comments also challenge the assumption that a successful ODI innings must always be built around a total above 300. On some pitches, a more measured approach and a score in the 260-270 range may be enough, provided the team bats with discipline and then executes with the ball. The fifth ODI offered one example of India defending 209, although that result alone does not establish a universal scoring benchmark.
For Gambhir and the current coaching group, the broader task is to turn the lessons from the series into a repeatable batting method. The immediate series ended with India winning 3-1, but the discussion raised by the fourth-ODI collapse remains relevant to the team’s longer-term preparation for the 2027 World Cup.
Frequently asked questions
Why did Ravi Shastri agree with Gautam Gambhir after India’s New Zealand series win?
Shastri agreed that India’s batting performance in difficult conditions needed attention, particularly after the team was bowled out for 89 in the fourth ODI. He said players must apply themselves and negotiate periods when pitches assist fast bowlers, rather than always aiming for totals above 300.
What did Gautam Gambhir say about the 2027 ODI World Cup conditions?
After the fourth ODI defeat, Gambhir said New Zealand’s conditions were close to what India might encounter at the 2027 ODI World Cup in South Africa. He said being bowled out for around 90 was a concern and explained that the speed of the collapse was also disappointing.
How did India perform in the fifth ODI against New Zealand?
India scored 209 in the fifth ODI and won by 22 runs to seal the series 3-1. The report said Arshdeep Singh and Mohammed Siraj led the bowling effort that helped defend the modest total.
What score did Ravi Shastri say could be match-winning on some pitches?
Shastri said teams cannot always target 300-320 and that 260-270 can be a match-winning score on some tracks. His point was that batting plans need to account for conditions and that players may have to show patience when fast bowlers are favoured.