Key points
- Cricket Australia said Pat Cummins would retain its backing as Test captain amid renewed allegations about the 2018 Cape Town ball-tampering scandal.
- Cameron Bancroft's detailed account supported earlier claims by Usman Khawaja that knowledge of the plan extended beyond the three players who were sanctioned.
- Cummins has repeatedly denied knowing that sandpaper was being used and called Khawaja's claims that he helped plan the scheme nonsense.
- Josh Hazlewood publicly backed Cummins and said he would have to consider his own position if Cummins were removed as captain.
- Cricket Australia's board unanimously reaffirmed Cummins as captain on 21 November after chair David Boon and CEO Todd Greenberg met him.
- Cummins said he supported an independent forum for players and staff connected to the 2018 tour and intended to participate.
- Australia are scheduled to begin their Test series against New Zealand in Perth on 9 December.
Pat Cummins will continue as Australia's Test captain with the backing of Cricket Australia, despite renewed scrutiny over the 2018 ball-tampering scandal that has once again unsettled Australian cricket. The fast bowler has faced questions after fresh accounts from former team-mates reignited debate about how widely the Newlands plan was known within the touring group.
The immediate issue for Cricket Australia (CA) was whether the controversy would affect Cummins' position ahead of the home side's next Test assignment. The governing body had repeatedly expressed confidence in its captain and indicated he would be allowed to continue in the role he has held since 2021. On 21 November, the CA board made that backing explicit with a unanimous show of support after a meeting involving chair David Boon, chief executive Todd Greenberg and Cummins.
Fresh claims bring the 2018 controversy back into focus
The latest round of scrutiny followed a detailed account from Cameron Bancroft, who was caught using sandpaper on the ball during the third Test against South Africa at Newlands in Cape Town in 2018. Bancroft's account supported claims previously made by former Australia batter Usman Khawaja that knowledge of the plan to alter the ball's condition extended beyond the three players who were formally sanctioned.
Bancroft wrote that he had conversations with the bowlers about the amount of swing the ball was producing and alleged that the wider group of players and coaches celebrated when the ball-tampering brought success. His account also implicated members of the coaching staff from that tour, including then head coach Darren Lehmann and bowling coach David Saker. These are allegations and should be distinguished from the disciplinary findings made in 2018.
The original sanctions were imposed on Bancroft, then captain Steve Smith and vice-captain David Warner. Smith and Warner were suspended, while Bancroft also received a ban. The scandal became one of the most damaging episodes in modern Australian cricket and led to major scrutiny of the team's culture and leadership.
Cummins maintains his denial
Cummins has consistently denied knowing that sandpaper was being used on the field during the Cape Town Test. He was a member of the Australia team on the tour but was not captain at the time. In a lengthy media conference in Sydney the previous week, he addressed the claims directly and rejected Khawaja's suggestion that the entire team knew about the plan.
The fast bowler described the allegation that he and other players were architects of a ball-tampering scheme as completely false. He said he wanted to answer the questions surrounding his role so that Australian cricket could move forward rather than remain trapped in repeated arguments about the same episode.
Bancroft said Cummins' media appearance was the final factor that prompted him to publish his own account. He described feeling angry, betrayed and alone, and set out his recollection in a statement of more than 4,000 words. The contrasting accounts have kept the issue in the headlines and raised questions about what the wider group knew at the time.
Cricket Australia and team-mates rally behind the captain
Cricket Australia's position was that Cummins would retain its support as the team prepared for the next international assignment. The board's unanimous backing on 21 November reinforced that stance. Boon praised the culture developed under Cummins and other senior leaders, while the organisation said it rejected implications that the captain's integrity had been compromised.
Fast bowler Josh Hazlewood also spoke publicly in support of his long-time team-mate. Hazlewood said he wanted to back Cummins and his account of events, and praised the captain's work in building the team over the previous five or six years. He suggested that removing Cummins would create a difficult situation inside the dressing room and said he would have to consider his own position if that happened.
Hazlewood was also part of the 2018 touring party and has denied knowing that sandpaper was being used. His comments underline the significance of the issue for the current group, with the captaincy debate now intersecting with questions about team unity and the way the players want the episode addressed.
Independent forum and the focus on New Zealand series
Cricket Australia has indicated that an independent forum will provide an opportunity for players and staff connected to the 2018 tour to share their accounts. Cummins has welcomed the process and said he intends to take part. He has acknowledged that difficult conversations will be necessary if Australian cricket is to address the lingering questions around the scandal.
For now, the captain's immediate responsibility is preparing the team for the next Test series. Australia are scheduled to face New Zealand in the opening Test in Perth on 9 December. At the time of the original BBC report, the squad for the first match had not been named. Cummins has shown no public indication that he plans to step away from the captaincy.
The renewed debate has placed the 2018 events back under an intense spotlight, but Cricket Australia's decision gives the current captain a clear mandate to continue. The independent forum may provide further accounts of what happened in South Africa, while the team will attempt to keep its attention on the cricket ahead.
Frequently asked questions
Will Pat Cummins remain Australia's Test captain?
Yes. Cricket Australia has backed Cummins to continue, and its board unanimously reaffirmed that support on 21 November. Cummins has not indicated that he intends to resign and has said his focus is on leading Australia in the upcoming Test series against New Zealand.
Why has Pat Cummins' captaincy come under scrutiny?
The debate has resurfaced after Cameron Bancroft published a detailed account supporting earlier claims by Usman Khawaja that knowledge of the 2018 ball-tampering plan extended beyond the players who were punished. Cummins has consistently denied knowing sandpaper was being used.
What has Josh Hazlewood said about Cummins?
Hazlewood has publicly backed Cummins, praising his leadership over the past five or six years. He said he would have to think about his own position if Cummins were forced to stand down, and stressed that he did not know sandpaper was being used during the 2018 Test.
What is the independent forum on the 2018 South Africa tour?
Cricket Australia has proposed an independent forum where players and staff connected to the 2018 tour can give their accounts. Cummins has said he supports the process completely and intends to attend, describing difficult conversations as necessary.
When does Australia next play a Test match?
Australia are scheduled to face New Zealand in the first Test of their upcoming series in Perth on 9 December. At the time of the BBC report, the squad for the opening match had not yet been announced.